Who Do You Trust? The Consequences of Partisanship and Trust for Responsiveness to COVID-19 Orders

Perspectives on Politics, 2021

Recommended citation: Goldstein, Daniel AN, and Johannes Wiedemann. (2021). "Who Do You Trust? The Consequences of Partisanship and Trust for Responsiveness to COVID-19 Orders" Perspectives on Politics. 1(1). https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-politics/article/who-do-you-trust-the-consequences-of-partisanship-and-trust-for-public-responsiveness-to-covid19-orders/466134E376AD87F52441F26F3BE7D653#article

Non-uniform compliance with public policy by citizens can undermine the effectiveness of government, particularly during crises. Mitigation policies intended to combat the novel coronavirus offer a real-world measure of citizen compliance, allowing us to examine the determinants of asymmetrical responsiveness. Analyzing county-level cellphone data, we leverage staggered roll-out to estimate the causal effect of stay-at-home orders on mobility using a difference-in-differences strategy. We find movement is significantly curtailed, and examination of descriptive heterogeneous effects suggests the key roles that partisanship and trust play in producing irregular compliance. We find that Republican-leaning counties comply less than Democratic-leaning ones, which we argue underlines the importance of trust in science and acceptance of large-scale government policies for compliance. However, this partisan compliance gap shrinks when directives are given by Republican leaders, suggesting citizens are more trusting of co-partisan leaders. Furthermore, we find that higher levels of social trust increase compliance; yet, these gains attenuate or intensify depending upon community-level partisan sentiments. Our study provides a real-world, behavioral measure that demonstrates the influence of partisanship, social trust, and their interaction on citizen welfare. Finally, we argue our results speak to how trust in government may impact successful containment of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The paper was covered in USApp - American Politics and Policy Blog by the LSE, see USApp Blog Post

Download paper here

Click here for Replication Data and Code